Part B

Directions :

In the following text, some sentences have been removed. For Questions 41-45, choose the most suitable one from the list A-G to fit into each of the numbered blanks. There are two extra choices, which do not fit in any of the blanks. Mark your answers on the ANSWER SHEET. (10 points)


How does your reading proceed? Clearly you try to comprehend, in the sense of identifying meanings for individual words and working out relationships between them, drawing on your implicit knowledge of English grammar. (41) CIf you are unfamiliar with words or idioms, you guess at their meaning, using clues presented in the context. On the assumption that they will become relevant later, you make a mental note of discourse entities as well as possible links between them. You begin to infer a context for the text, for instance, by making decisions about what kind of speech event is involved: Who is making the utterance, to whom, when and where.

The ways of reading indicated here are without doubt kinds of comprehension. But they show comprehension to consist not just of passive assimilation but of active engagement in inference and problem-solving. You infer information you feel the writer has invited you to grasp by presenting you with specific evidence and clues. (42) EYou make further inferences, for instance, about how the text may be significant to you, or about its validity——inferences that form the basis of a personal response for which the author will inevitably be far less responsible.

Conceived in this way, comprehension will not follow exactly the same track for each reader, What is in question is not the retrieval of an absolute, fixed ortruemeaning that can be read off and checked for accuracy, or some timeless relation of the text to the world. (43) GRather, we ascribe meanings to texts on the basis of interaction between what we might call textual and contextual material: between kinds of organization or patterning we perceive in a text's formal structures (so especially its language structures) and various kinds of background, social knowledge, belief and attitude that we bring to the text.

Such background material inevitably reflects who we are. (44) BFactors such as the place and period in which we are reading, our gender, ethnicity, age and social class will encourage us towards certain interpretations but at the same time obscure or even close off others. This doesn't, however, make interpretation merely relative or even pointless. Precisely because readers from different historical periods, places and social experiences produce different but overlapping readings of the same words on the page——including for texts that engage with fundamental human concerns——debates about texts can play an important role in social discussion of beliefs and values.

How we read a given text also depends to some extent on our particular interest in reading it. (45) AAre we studying that text and trying to respond in a way that fulfils the requirement of a given course? Reading it simply for pleasure? Skimming it for information? Ways of reading on a train or in bed are likely to differ considerably from reading in a seminar room. Such dimensions of reading suggest——as others introduced later in the book will also do——that we bring an implicit (often unacknowledged) agenda to any act of reading. It doesn't then necessarily follow that one kind of reading is fuller, more advanced or more worthwhile than another. Ideally, different kinds of reading inform each other, and act as useful reference points for and counterbalances to one another. Together, they make up the reading component of your overall literacy, or relationship to your surrounding textual environment.


【总体分析】:

本文摘自 2006年出版的一本名为 Ways of Reading: Advanced Reading Skills for Students of English Literature《阅读的方法:英语文学专业高级阅读技巧》的书籍。真题选用部分介绍了阅读理解的基本过程并对此进行评论。

  1. 【C】

    If you are unfamiliar with words or idioms, you guess at their meaning, using clues presented in the context. On the assumption that they will become relevant later, you make a mental note of discourse entities as well as possible links between them.

    解析

    空格前文提出文章主题“如何进行阅读”,并指出阅读环节之一“确定单词意思,理解文本含义”。后文则指出阅读的另一更深层次的环节“推理文本语境”。【C】“利用上下文线索猜测不认识词汇的含义;记住文本中语篇实体及其可能存在的联系”在文义上能和上下文顺接,且第一句偏重承接上文,第二句趋于靠拢下文;选项的 words or idioms/their meaning 回应上文 meanings for individual words;且和上下文一体,实现话题从“词(words)”到“语篇实体(discourse entities)”,再到“语境(context)”的过渡。

  2. 【E】

    You make further inferences, for instance, about how the text may be significant to you, or about its validity——inferences that form the basis of a personal response for which the author will inevitably be far less responsible.

    解析

    第二段第一、二句指出“阅读理解过程不仅包括被动接收,还应主动推理和解决问题”,随后第三句指出读者应基于文中线索进行推理,抓住作者希望你抓住的内容。【E】指出“读者应继续深入推理,超越文本本身”,能和前文顺利衔接;原文的 active engagement in inference and problem-solving ... You infer information...和选项的 you make further inference...完整一体,说明“阅读过程中应如何进行推理”。

  3. 【G】

    Rather, we ascribe meanings to texts on the basis of interaction between what we might call textual and contextual material: between kinds of organization or patterning we perceive in a text's formal structures (so especially its language structures) and various kinds of background, social knowledge, belief and attitude that we bring to the text.

    解析

    第三段首句指出“每个人的阅读轨迹不尽相同”,第二句反向澄清首句信息,指出问题不在于复核文中绝对的、固定的信息及亘古不变的关系。【G】所述内容“而是基于文本材料和语境材料的相互联系来理解文本含义”能够和原文第二句构成正、反说明,共同解释首句具体所指;段落第二句中 What is in question is not ...,...,or...与【G】中 Rather ...形成完整逻辑关系(问题不是……而是……);且【G】中 various kinds of background,social knowledge, belief and attitude 还能与第四段首句的 Such background material 形成照应。

  4. 【B】

    Factors such as the place and period in which we are reading, our gender, ethnicity, age and social class will encourage us towards certain interpretations but at the same time obscure or even close off others.

    解析

    第四段首句指出“一些背景信息无疑会反映出读者的个人身份/特质(who we are)”。空格后两句转而指出读者千差万别的背景信息能起到明显的积极作用。【B】指出“读者的个人特质”会影响其对文本的解读,使其带上明显的个人主观色彩,既能和上文顺接,又能和下文构成转折关系。其中 Factors such as the place and period...呼应首句 Such background material; will encourage us towards certain interpretations but at the same time obscure or even close off others 说明个人背景因素会使我们对文本的解读带有明显的主观性(似乎是一件不好的事情),能和下文 can play an important role in...体现的“积极作用”构成转折。

  5. 【A】

    Are we studying that text and trying to respond in a way that fulfils the requirement of a given course? Reading it simply for pleasure? Skimming it for information? Ways of reading on a train or in bed are likely to differ considerably from reading in a seminar room.

    解析

    第五段首句指出“如何阅读在一定程度上也取决于读者对文本的特殊兴趣”,下文则指出不同层面的阅读会影响我们的阅读行为,such dimensions ofreading 以其回指功能暗示空格处列举了不同层面的阅读。【A】通过并列设问及直接举例的方式指出“读者的阅读目的不同,则阅读方式也不同”,既例证说明了首句内容,也契合下文 such dimensions of reading 所指,与上下文衔接顺畅。

【全文翻译】:

你如何进行阅读?显然,你设法从确定每个单词的意思、理清词与词之间的关系、动用你对英语语法的隐性知识这些角度去理解文本。(41)【C】如果不熟悉某些单词或习语,可以利用上下文出现的线索来猜测词义。假设这些语篇实体在后文中相互联系,读者(在阅读时)需要将语篇实体及其之间的联系记在脑中。(然后)你开始推理文本的语境,比如,确定涉及何种言语事件:谁在说话,对谁说话,什么时间,什么地点。

确实,这里所介绍的阅读方法属于理解类。但这些方法表明阅读理解不仅包括被动地接受吸收,还包括主动参与推理和解决问题。推理那些你认为作者希望通过具体论据和线索的呈现而想让你抓住的信息;(42)【E】读者可以继续深入推理,比如,文本对你有何意义,或文本效度如何——这些推理构成读者个人反应的基础,必然与作者关系甚微。

这样看来,每位读者的阅读理解轨迹并不完全相同。问题不是复核那些可以准确读出或查出的文本的绝对的、固定的或“真实的”意思,也不是找出文本与世界的某些永恒联系。(43)【G】而是要根据我们称之为文本信息和语境信息这两者之间的相互联系来理解文义,也即,根据我们对文本格式结构(特别是语言结构)的理解,如文中的组织架构、行文模式和我们阅读文本时的各种背景信息、社会认知、信仰、态度这两方面的联系来理解文本。

这些背景信息必然会反映出读者的个人特质。(44)【B】诸如阅读地点、时间,读者的性别、种族、年龄和社会阶层这些因素都会促使读者倾向于某种解读,但与此同时屏蔽或拒绝其他解读。然而,这并不会使我们对文本的解读仅仅具有相对性,甚至毫无意义。恰恰是因为处于不同历史时期、来自不同地方、拥有不同社会经历的读者对书中相同文本——包括那些涉及人类关心的根本性问题的文本——产生不同但却相互重叠的解读,关于这些文本的讨论才在有关信仰和价值观的社会讨论中起着重要作用。

如何阅读某一特定文本一定程度上也取决于读者对该文本的特殊兴趣。(45)【A】学习某一文本以试图通过某种回应方式来完成一门指定课程的要求?还是仅仅因为乐趣而阅读?亦或是为了获取信息而快速浏览?乘火车或躺在床上时的阅读方式可能与坐在讨论室中的阅读方式差异甚远。这些层面的阅读表明——以及其他将要在后文介绍的阅读层面也表明——读者将某种潜在的(通常未被意识到的)过程带入到了所有阅读活动中来。没有必要认为一种阅读层面比另外一种更充分、更高级、更有价值。理想的情况是,不同层面的阅读方式相互补充,彼此之间互为有用的参考点,相互平衡。它们共同构成了读者整体知识素养的阅读部分,或者说它们共同构成了读者周围文本环境的关联。